Run an AI Decision-Routing Tabletop for New Managers
SimplSolutions Editorial Team · 5 min read · Published

The management decision is different from answer checking
A team member may bring a manager an AI-assisted recommendation that is polished, specific, and ready to use. The manager’s task is not simply to decide whether the wording sounds credible. It is to decide what the team can do next with the recommendation.
That is a distinct management skill. A recommendation may have strong evidence but still need a local approval. It may be easy to check but not yet checked. Or it may rest on incomplete or conflicting material, making a routine decision inappropriate.
A tabletop exercise can help new managers practice this judgment before it arises in live work. The goal is not to make managers technical AI evaluators. It is to give them a common way to discuss evidence, authority, and next actions when AI-assisted work reaches their team.
Keep provenance separate from decision quality
Anthropic’s research on provable inference describes a cryptographic approach intended to let a user verify that a response was produced by a particular claimed model. The research describes FlashProve as a prototype and characterizes the work as intermediate progress.
For a manager tabletop, that creates a useful distinction:
- Was the response produced by the claimed system?
- Does the recommendation have evidence that fits this decision?
- What action is appropriate under the team’s established process?
Provenance concerns the first question. It does not itself show that a recommendation is current, that its inputs are complete, or that it fits a particular policy or situation.
This distinction prevents a common shortcut: treating a system label, a citation, or polished language as a decision-ready basis. The relevant management question is whether the available evidence and the next action match the work at hand.
Use a two-part routing model
Do not place evidence states and actions in the same list. They answer different questions and can coexist.
First: describe the evidence status
- Established: A relevant source, record, or procedure can be inspected and supports the recommendation in this situation.
- Incomplete: The recommendation lacks an inspectable basis, its applicability is unclear, or a needed input is missing.
- Conflicting: Available sources, records, or interpretations point in different directions.
A citation is not automatically established evidence. The cited material must be relevant and actually support the conclusion.
Then: choose the next action
- Use within defined authority: The evidence is established and the decision sits within the manager’s locally defined remit.
- Perform a defined check: A reliable comparison, calculation, or review can resolve an incomplete point before acting.
- Route for review: The evidence remains incomplete or conflicting, or the decision belongs with another owner under the organization’s established process.
This structure allows an answer to be both well supported and independently checkable. It also makes routing an action decision rather than an evidence label.
A manager tabletop: the fictional exception request
Use an approved internal case with sensitive details removed, or use a clearly fictional scenario. The following exercise is hypothetical and does not describe an actual policy or approval rule.
Scenario: A team member asks an AI assistant to draft a recommendation about an exception request. The draft says that the request can be approved because similar requests were approved previously. It names no record, procedure, or decision owner.
Ask each group to identify:
- The specific recommendation the manager is being asked to make.
- What would count as established evidence for that recommendation.
- Which information is incomplete or could conflict with other records.
- Whether a defined check could resolve the issue.
- Which next action follows under the organization’s local authority and review process.
The group should not vote on whether the draft sounds reasonable. It should complete the two-part routing model: evidence status first, action second.
Facilitate the discussion without inventing rules
A facilitator can reveal additional fictional information in rounds. For example, a participant may be told that an applicable procedure exists but its conditions have not been reviewed. The evidence status remains incomplete; opening and comparing the procedure may be a defined check.
In a later round, the fictional procedure and a prior decision record may appear to point in different directions. The status becomes conflicting. The appropriate action depends on the organization’s established process, not on a universal escalation rule.
Useful prompts include:
- What claim is the recommendation making?
- Which source or record would need to support it?
- Does that material apply to this case?
- What check could resolve the uncertainty?
- Who owns the next decision if the uncertainty remains?
These are adaptable considerations for manager training. They do not replace local policy, delegation, or review requirements.
What a successful tabletop produces
The output is a shared decision record, not a score for spotting bad AI writing. Each group should be able to state the recommendation, its evidence status, the check performed or proposed, and the chosen next action.
That record helps managers distinguish three situations that can look similar in a chat window: work that is ready to use within their authority, work that needs a specific check, and work that should move to an established reviewer or process.
For a first session, use one fictional scenario and keep the discussion focused on routing. In later sessions, teams can adapt the exercise to their own approved workflows, decision boundaries, and evidence sources.
The practical outcome is not blanket skepticism of AI-assisted work. It is a more disciplined management conversation: What supports this recommendation, what remains uncertain, and what should happen next?



